Asklemmy

To be clear, as an admin of beehaw, we are not explicitly against any ideologies.

Yes you are, you explicitly block the communist lemmy.

What are you going to do when Hexbear federates? It's a mixed communist and anarchist space 20x bigger than the rest of lemmy combined filled with people that explicitly adore China, defend, stand behind the position that NATO is primarily responsible for this war and that it has now reached a point at which the only way the war can end is for Russia to win because Ukraine's psychotic leadership has banned every anti-war party and closed every tv channel that had an anti-war lean. The outcome of this means the left opposes sending weapons to Ukraine because it prolongs the war and the suffering it causes.

This probably sounds wild to you as a liberal. But all of this isn't a controversial position among socialists, it's pretty standard here in Britain among the socialist left and if you take any time to go looking at what American socialists are saying you'd find it's also the case among them too. For example the DSA's current position.

I think really what's happening with you guys is that you don't realise how far right you are, you support Biden right? The fuckhead is to the right of the Tories. Over here you'd be a Tory and this is the British left's discourse on that.

I think you guys have absolutely no idea just how far right you are and how completely insulated from the REAL left in the world you actually are. You live in a media landscape completely captured by capital (which you support) that maintains a bubble that utterly deplatforms the organised and educated working class who know where their interests lie from any kind of participation. When you exit your corporate media bubbles and see the real left you undergo a considerable culture shock. I consider you, a Biden supporter, far right. You're fundamentally to the right of bloody Thatcher on every economic issue and my street celebrates her death with a fucking party every single year.

Painting us as ‘against communists’ just because we’ve blocked an instance which does nothing to prevent or discourage specific kinds of speech which are anything but nice, is unfair.

"The socialists are too mean so we block them!" is the most bullshit excuse ever. It is far more to do with blocking socialism and the left than it is to do with the way people speak, you're just blocking the left via the usual liberal methods of making up barriers that would defacto capture most of the left. This is the same tactic as the racists in America that don't explicitly target the black community but instead write policies that would overwhelmingly affect them and not white communities because the policies target issues that are prevalent within black communities.

What do I mean by this? Tone policing explicitly targets working class people. You want to control the manner in which I express myself, the manner in which I speak. You want to demand that I speak in your suitably middle-income white suburbanite american accepted manner of speaking. If I don't "speak right" then you want to kick me out of your spaces. This kind of policy OVERWHELMINGLY targets working class people because it is working class people that come from backgrounds where the way we are brought up is less privileged, where expression between one another is not a priority compared to figuring out how I'm going to pay the scumsucking landlord last month's rent which is now 6 weeks late while feeding the rest of the family while energy prices have risen 500%.

Don't police people for how they speak, you create bubbles that don't include working class people by doing this.

People should be policed for what they say, not how they say it.

By taking on the policy approaches that you have, you have built an explicitly anti-working-class space, which by extension is anti-communist because socialists are the real representatives of the working class. You've done exactly what spaces like /r/politics did to alienate the working class and create the most horrifically right wing liberal hellholes imaginable.