Hi, recently I thought about lemmy and came into the conclusion, that it lacks one thing to be a true competition for reddit and stackoverflow and that is the search engine and user visibility.

Let's say I want to fix some issue on my computer. I type the question into the browser and what?... first 3 links lead to reddit, stackoverflow some random website or eventually quora. If there was answer to my question on any lemmy instance, I'd be lucky if it was on any of the 3 first browser pages. Also the fact, that the links of lemmy instances look well.... not so standard, doesen't help.

I think the solution would be to create one "central" instance, which wouldn't have any users, but instead would aggregate posts from technical forums of other isntances. It would greatly improve search engine visibility and provide centralized access to content without dropping the federation philosophy. It would also help creating a brand, as everyone instead of searching for answers on reddit etc. would just go to lemmyhelp.xyz and look there, knowing it's somewhat trusted and official source. Also moderation on such site would be MUCH easier, than on reddit or SO.

What do you think?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] xilliah@beehaw.org 4 points 1 year ago

To be absolutely honest I like Lemmy as it is right now. If it popped up in popular search engines it would attract a more general audience which I have never experienced to be a good thing.

I suppose it's a bit like those beautiful old towns where everyone knows each other, and then suddenly it shows up in search somewhere and suddenly you have all the touries ruining the place.

Also I like that every place is unique, and I wouldn't mind it it became more so. Globalism and modern design has really done a number on turning everything monotone and oversimplified.