Even anarchists are not immune to reproducing carcerality. There have been moments where revolutionary anarchists in the Spanish and Ukrainian Revolutions reproduced policing with militants of the Federación Anarquista Ibérica even operating a concentration camp for fascists. More recently, we have seen carcerality reproduced in radical projects like the Capitol Hill Occupied Protest. There, individuals who took it upon themselves to act as the new people’s police shot and killed Black teens. It matters not if the anarcho-concentration camp was leagues better than Stalinist gulags or if the anarcho-police are somehow better; abolition means the doing away of the anarcho-police and anarcho-prisons as well.
I think Magsalin puts too fine a point on it here, and is directly contradicted by the Bonanno quote he uses. The black teens in question stole a Jeep Cherokee in the middle of the night after stabbing its owner with a pickaxe, drove it through the Autonomous Zone barricade and reportedly fired haphazardly at people trying to escape while weaving erratically on the grass where people were sleeping in the park. Volunteers, organized and armed by other young black people in response to violent threats by fascist vigilantes and cars driving by the barricades and firing into the camp, fired back and stopped the vehicle. They successfully defended the autonomous zone from terror caused for the benefit of the state, and even used their volunteer medical services to get the injured assailants medical attention and saved the younger black child's life.
The death of Antonio Mays Jr. was tragic, but in losing his life, other lives may have been saved. How does condemning the commune's self-defense not completely contradict "Hurry comrade, shoot the policeman, the judge, the boss... Hurry to arm yourself" ? One reading would suggest Bonanno would celebrate both teens' summary execution. The purpose of police is to defend capital, it is not merely a person with a cause and a gun. The defenders of the movement on Chapel Hill saved lives, even those that belonged to their enemies.