this post was submitted on 24 Aug 2024
4 points (100.0% liked)

One Piece

546 readers
1 users here now

Discussion of all Grand Line stuff, fanart and theories regarding Eiichiro Oda's anime One Piece.

Rules:

  1. Topic: Posts must be related to One Piece
  2. Tags: Lemmy doesn’t have tags yet, so please mark posts with [Episode/Chapter], [Fanart], [Question], [Discussion], [Theory] or others you may think are appropriate. e.g. [Theory, ep1/ch1]: this guy with the hat will be pirate king!
  3. Spoilers: No spoilers in titles, tag posts containing spoilers as such!
  4. Behavior: No spam, personal attacks, racism, sexism and any other discrimination (in short: don't be a jerk in any way - Code of Conduct).
  5. Spam: Please do not spam
  6. NSFW: Please refrain from posting NSFW/Hentai content

Please DM the mod(s) if you see violations that are not handled in time.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
mr_pip@discuss.tchncs.de
4
[Theory chapter 1124+] The defense Hierarchy of Elbaph (links.hackliberty.org)
submitted 2 months ago by overflowingmemory@links.hackliberty.org to c/onepiece@discuss.tchncs.de
4 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 

[Theory chapter 1124+] The defense Hierarchy of Elbaph

Are Giant Warrior Pirates the Giant army?

Supposedly the giants have the strongest army in the world (according to BigMom), yet we have seen the giant warrior pirates lackluster performance. Of course they tanked the egghead buster call quite well, and even played with battleships like Toyboats, but this pirate crew does not seem worthy of a Yonko Bigmoms attention. The giant pirates do not use Haki and only brute strength, like their giant archers sinking boats with .... giant arrows. Their captains Dorry and Broggy may only use Haki with their strongest attack -- Hakoku sovereignty.

Warland

This lead me to the theory that the giant warrior pirates are outcasts and joked about for their weakness by the true warriors of Elbaph who live deep inside the island. Elbaph may be organized in multiple defense rings, where each ring is at war with its neighbors. This would explain the name Warland Elbaph, a land at constant war with itself to evolve a capable growing defense against outside invasion forces. Giants seem to be thick headed, easy to anger and its common among them to fight decades long battles for forgettable reasons as Dorry and Broggy have shown.

The Defense Realms of Elbaf

So let me characterize the defense rings / realms / levels of Elbaph:

  • Outer defense Belt: Pirate outcasts live at the coast.
    • the coast is defended by pirates only ~ they do not like if outsiders point a gun at their hometown (RIP captain Kid)
    • Shanks has set up camp there, keeping a fragile peace
    • Government agents like Mother Caramel where only able to infiltrate this outermost ring, not further inland, before she got banished from the land for Big Moms tantrum.
    • Giant beasts comparable to the five elders beast transformations in size roam its forests, as Dorry and Broggy recount at egghead
    • frequent incursions by the inner rings force the pirates to escape outwards and seek fame and resources in foreign lands
    • giant mountain passes make it difficult to intrude further inland (as shown in the Shanks vs Kid Anime episode, these mountain scenery feels like the Alps of Heidi Girl of the Alps)
  • Inner Defense Ring: Giant Army fort
    • giants skilled in the use of Armament and Observation train here, hunting giant beasts.
    • the greatest honor is to become a personal guard of Prince Loki
    • the Palace guard of king Loki recruits from their ranks.
    • this is the Army of giants Big Mom wanted to attain by marrying Prince Loki with her daughter
  • Innermost ring: Yagdrasil / Adam tree
    • a giant tree seems to grow in the center of Elbaph. Perhaps its inspired by the legend of Yagdrassil "the world tree"
    • Prince Loki chills in the Palace and his honor guard reside here
    • Adam wood is sold here, making this region extremely rich.
    • Conquerors Haki users are common, nocking out approaching invaders with ease
  • ((Treetop)): The entire defense of Elbaph is centered to protect this treasure. Only a brave warrior of the sea can reach it ...
top 4 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] sabreW4K3@lazysoci.al 2 points 2 months ago (1 children)

I like the theory. Let's see if it holds up. No way is Elbaf as simple as we think and this arc needs to provide significant level ups for the whole crew. Some more than others.

[–] overflowingmemory@links.hackliberty.org 2 points 1 month ago (1 children)

Yeah, I thought Oda could reveal something about the lore and structure of Elbaf soon. So I decided the time was now or never to post this theory.

The name of the theory was partly based on the security architecture of operating systems, since Linux also uses privilege rings for securing the system against unauthorized access. Ring 0 has the highest privilege, any Virus would get into that ring.

Ring 0 would be Lokis mansion

[–] sabreW4K3@lazysoci.al 1 points 1 month ago (1 children)

So you think they're in Loki's mansion?

[–] overflowingmemory@links.hackliberty.org 1 points 1 month ago

I would think Prince Lokis Mansion would be defended by giant warrior guards. Instead we get some empty Mansion, defended by a house cat and a hedgehog - for a kings Mansion? I doubt it is Lokis home.

Never thought Elbaf had a Lego culture though lmao . And why are they only hedgehogs and a cats with a crown inside that Mansion? I mentioned Giant beasts in my theory, but did not think they looked domesticated like that.

The only thing for sure is: There are different sub-cultures on Elbaf. Shanks did not stay inside a house made out of Lego on Elbaf Bar with Dorry and Broggy. The Straw hats landed inside one of those giant Sub-Cultures.