this post was submitted on 09 May 2022
27 points (96.6% liked)
Asklemmy
43777 readers
1376 users here now
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- !lemmy411@lemmy.ca: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de~
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Literally described as being a community of "leftists"
I know, is there a lemmy look alike for idk centrists and for everyone else? I just created a voat account and was surprised by what I saw on r/askvoat. https://www.voat.xyz/viewpost?postid=626ee17071e64
I would choose lemmy anyday over that shit
If you're not keen on seeing posts from "right" leaning extremist, I'm not sure where to point you. "Centrist" communities are going to let that stuff slide, and obviously "right" focused communities are just going to be the most insane things you've ever seen
If you aren't a "Trump's America" apologist, you're best bet is to just find a "left" community of people that largely aren't extremists. Lemmy is fine, HexBear is okay... not sure what else though
I am actually a supporter of Trump's policies, although he is not fit to lead US after Jan 6. not a fucking racist like those folks at voat. I wonder what brings that out. That site makes me puke. Thanks for the reply tho. My respect for Lemmy greatly increased after visiting voat.
oh well, the centrist is really just a right winger, how shocking
I am not a centrist, I want to be in a platform with them.
I'm trying to extend Reddit's /r/moderatepolitics to !moderatepolitics@sopuli.xyz. The Reddit community isn't centrist per se, but more tries to produce a forum with a baseline level of respect during discussions. There are a pretty decent variety of viewpoints represented in the Reddit community, clustering vaguely in the ideological center. The outpost on Lemmy is currently dead, but that can change. :)
Jan 6 didn't just magically happen in isolation. Trump, through his public speeches, actively encouraged ideas and theories that lead to that. Jan 6 was merely the result, to think of Jan 6 as a thing he and a few thousand people woke up and did one day is not a useful way of analyzing how to avoid it happening again; preventative treatment is the most effective.
A bunch of things. Modern Republicans appeal strongly to anti-progressivism (to paraphrase, "we resist the woke leftist socialism of the politically correct Democrats!"), engage in STRONG patriotism and nationalism (keeping "the Mexicans" out) and more so some things like "good people on both sides" and failing to denounce the rise of white nationalist terrorism (intentionally or not) act as dog-whistles and tacit encouragement, so naturally those racist crowds flock to him. In the false binary of Democrat and Republican, their choice is obvious. That clearly doesn't mean 'Trump supporters must be racist', but it's absolutely no surprise those millions of people flock to him.
Of course, that doesn't mean Biden is good either. He's also absolute shit, along with approximately the entire Democrat party (protip: most of the world would consider them center-to-right wing in that dumb left-right spectrum, apart from a couple of small social progressive policies). The electoral system of the US is ineffective, and it's no surprise people are turning to radical groups in all directions in the past few years.
I agree and I felt sad that he did that. He was indifferent or positively ecstatic about the consequences of his speech. He put himself above the nation.
Again, I do think merit based immigration is a good thing, so as long as they want that I am not against them. (thank for the answer, I understand your point broadly. )
Maybe we need a dedicated thread, but "merit-based" immigration is a racist scam. When you go travel abroad with your fancy european/american ID, are you asked for the merits you're gonna bring to the countries you're visiting?
Why can i with a french passport travel anywhere in the former french colonies without a visa, while Mali/Senegal/etc citizens require a long process to acquire a visa?
What does it mean to judge people based on their "merit"? How is that evaluated? As someone born in France, should i be evaluated based on my merits too? Why do immigrants who wish to reside in France get indoctrinated/interrogated about about stories and ideas i disagree with as a french person? Why is it ok for me to disagree with the french Empire but not with immigrants?
I don't in absolute (and in isolation from other questions) disagree with the principle of chosen immigration. If we lived in an autonomous community and could only sustain 200 people, we'd have to be careful who we let in and how they can help the community thrive. But "chosen" immigration on a country-scale in some of the richest countries on earth where there's millions of empty dwellings and tons of wasted food is just a racist scam.
What would attract you about this idea? Why do you feel like it's even needed in the first place?
PS: See, we can have debates here on lemmy.ml too :P :P
Lemmy the platform is diverse, lemmy.ml is not, but it doesn't pretend to be. Did you look at the list of instances on https://join-lemmy.org/instances when choosing which one to join?
I guess it depends on the type of content do you want to engage in and what type of political discourse are you looking to engage in. Exploding-heads.com and wolfballs.com might be options, and beehaw.org has a politics section if you feel the need to engage. Also consider what instances the server blocks via the instances link at the bottom of the page when visiting.
Personally id love to see generalist instances push political discourse to gotalkitout https://gtio.io/c/politics which is a instance dedicated to discussion and currently does not block any instance.
I think the generalist ones like gtio.io are a solid idea, providing a mixing pot. That said, hope it doesn't get a culture shock and become the classical 'free speech' case where it's mostly just populated by people who feel censored elsewhere.
I also like the concept of 'no politics, no exceptions' communities, where that is appropriate (e.g. cat pictures). If I want serious politics, I'll go to a political discussion community instead of seeing people shoehorn their agenda into comments.
me too bruh!