this post was submitted on 25 Nov 2023
87 points (94.8% liked)

Linux

48012 readers
1038 users here now

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Linux is a family of open source Unix-like operating systems based on the Linux kernel, an operating system kernel first released on September 17, 1991 by Linus Torvalds. Linux is typically packaged in a Linux distribution (or distro for short).

Distributions include the Linux kernel and supporting system software and libraries, many of which are provided by the GNU Project. Many Linux distributions use the word "Linux" in their name, but the Free Software Foundation uses the name GNU/Linux to emphasize the importance of GNU software, causing some controversy.

Rules

Related Communities

Community icon by Alpár-Etele Méder, licensed under CC BY 3.0

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Hello, apparently hanging out in Lemmy inadvertently makes you thinking about using Linux. I am planning to install Linux Mint cinnamon on an older laptop, which I want to bring to LAN Parties. From what I read I can just format my C:\ windows disk, install Linux via bootable drive and from what I understand, proton is basically included when installing steam after setting up my new Linux OS? Thanks for your comments:)

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] KeenFlame@feddit.nu 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

He didn't imply that, he said he wanted to format C:\

Why is it oversimplifying to say the disk will be called / in Linux?

[–] TootSweet@lemmy.world 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

I just meant with the C: comment that OP shouldn't expect it to still be called C: after he's wiped Windows and is running Linux.

As for the oversimplification comment:

First off, C: (or D:, E: etc) doesn't refer to a disk in Windows. It refers to a partition. So it's entirely possible (and not terribly uncommon) to have a single disk with both a C: and a D: on it.

It's very typical for a Linux installation process to (by default, if you don't tell it to do something else) make separate partitions on a single disk for / and /home. (Plus there's usually an extra EFI boot partition on most modern desktop/laptop systems. And a swap partition.) In such a case, you couldn't really describe where "the disk" (that was formerly called C: on Windows) was mounted in the mindset of conflating "partition" with "disk". What was previously "the disk" C: (again, C: isn't a disk, it's a partition, but Windows makes it easy to conflate the two) is now split in two (or three or more) and mounted not just on / but also on /home (and maybe on /boot as well, and maybe one partition isn't mounted on the main abstract root filesystem).

/ and /home aren't really even partitions (let alone disks). They're mount points in the slightly more abstract root filesystem.

The most obvious software representation on a typical Linux system of the main internal disk in that machine would probably be something like /dev/sda or /dev/nvme0. The partitions would likely be something like /dev/sda1//dev/sda2/etc or /dev/nvme0p1//dev/nvme0p2/etc. Also, the "filesystem" on the partition is arguably a subtlely a distinct concept from the block device that is the partition. And where that filesystem is mounted is yet another distinct concept. (Another subtlety I haven't mentioned is the distinction between the device in the /dev/ directory/filesystem and the kernel representation of the device with the device major/minor numbers.)

A typical Windows install kindof conflates a lot of these probably a lot more so than Linux does. But I didn't want to be like "akshuly things are a lot more complicated than that and you have to understand a bunch of Linux kernel internals to understand all the ways in which you're wrong so you can install the holy 'Guh-noo Plus Linux'." All that is stuff that OP will learn by installing and using Linux. And if OP's going with Mint, it's probably not necessary to really understand all of that before starting the install process.

And technically OP doesn't really need to understand that the main disk won't be called C: after switching to Linux. Probably. (I don't think I've ever installed Mint. So I don't know for sure, but from what I've heard about it, I'd be surprised if the installation process had much of a learning curve.) But I told OP anyway. So there. :D

[–] KeenFlame@feddit.nu 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Okay thank you. I feel like it's a lot of information here that is about, like you say, how complicated abstract and advanced it is, with the devices, kernel representations and mount points.

There must be a better way of just explaining how the root fs works, because I still don't understand anything.

It really doesn't feel like comparing it to windows gives any favours though, maybe explain use cases, like where would the user save downloads, where would you install apps?

I've used Linux a little. Right now it's modernized enough for me to not learn the file system. But I remember in old times when I ran Ubuntu I just crammed files in a folder and struggled a lot with it

[–] TootSweet@lemmy.world 2 points 11 months ago

Ok. Lessee.

Just to quickly explain first off:

  • A disk is just a big collection of bytes. A 100GB disk has 100 billion(-ish) bytes. Each one has an index. The first byte has index "0". The second has index "1". There's a byte 8,675,309. Each byte has a particular value at any one time. The computer can set the value of any byte to any value. (It could set byte 8,675,309 to 01100001 and later it can reliably be read back from the same index as the same value, until it's changed to a different value.)
  • A disk can be divided into partitions. Basically you (or rather a tool you use) writes data to a location near the beginning of the disk that says "treat this disk as multiple separate devices. The first starts at byte X and ends at byte Y, the second starts at Y and ends at Z, etc."
  • When you plug a disk into a Linux computer (on most modern full-featured desktop/laptop Linux systems, though maybe not on, for instance, some embedded systems) a new "file" appears in /dev for the disk along with more files for each of the partitions on the disk. For instance, an external USB hard drive with three partitions might show up as /dev/sda and the partitions as /dev/sda1, /dev/sda2, and /dev/sda3 respectively. (Ok. Technically the things in /dev are only files in some senses. They're technically "devices". But they have paths like files do and they can be read from and written to like files.)
  • If you want to, you can read and write to those partitions or to the disk directly as you would read or write any file. You can open it in a text editor, for instance. You might get lots of random-looking broken characters if you do that, and god help you if you try to save over it, but you can. If you read from a disk or partition, it just returns all the bytes in the disk or partition starting from the first (or from whichever index your application asks it to start from.)
  • A "filesystem driver" knows how to interpret the bytes on a partition as files and directories.
  • If you want to know what device in /dev a file lives on and what filesystem driver is used for that device, the mount command just typed into any bash terminal will tell you. It'll output rows like on type (...). If you read/write a file or list a directory, it'll pick the entry in the mount output that has the longest that is a prefix of the requested file. The is the "file"(/device) in /dev that corresponds to the parition on which that file is encoded. `` is the name of the filesystem driver. So, for instance, if I have an entry /dev/sdb3 on /mnt/pringles type ext4 (...) and I read a file named /mnt/pringles/apple/unicorn/potato.txt (and if there are no entries in the mount output with longer paths that are still prefixes of the requested file path), the kernel will ask the ext4 filesystem driver to please look at the partition /dev/sdb3 and interpret that partition's contents as a hierarchical filesystem to find and return the contents of the file at the path apple/unicorn/potato.txt relative to the root of the filesystem encoded on the /dev/sdb3 partition.
  • There are other filesystem drivers that don't deal with disks. Some like tmpfs store data in RAM only (and RAM isn't intended to be persistent, so you can't expect anything in a tmpfs to last reliably through a reset.) Others like procfs don't look at a disk but make these ephemeral files that basically decide what data to return when read from at the time they're read from. (Files in procfs filesystems usually expose data about the Linux system. Like, for instance, what processes are currently running.)

Now, the question of where files should go is... kinda unrelated to the above. Files that are system-wide configuration should go in /etc. Files that are system-wide executables should generally go in /bin, /sbin, /usr/bin, /usr/sbin, and /usr/local/bin. Anything your own user downloads/creates should go in /home/$username. Etc. More specifics of all this here.

It can be useful to make decisions regarding what disk/partition a particular directory like /home lives on. But whether /home is on the same partition with /etc and /bin and /var etc or whether it's on a different partition (and both of these options are quite common), your users' files should go somewhere in /home.

To elucidate a little more, if you decide to put your /home on the same partition as /bin and /etc and /var and such, you'll have an entry in your mount output like /dev/sda2 on / type ext4 but nothing with a `` of /home. If you decide to put /home on a separate partition, you'll have your /dev/sda2 on / type ext4 entry plus another entry like /dev/sda3 on /home type ext4.

So which partition does a file go on when you write a file to /home/keenflame/document.txt? Well, in the first case, it'd be on the partition Linux calls /dev/sda2. In the second case it would be written to the partition that Linux calls /dev/sda3.