this post was submitted on 21 Jun 2023
5 points (100.0% liked)
Do It Yourself
7718 readers
1 users here now
Make it, Fix it, Renovate it, Rehabilitate it - as long as you’ve done some part of it yourself, share!
Especially for gardening related or specific do-it-yourself projects, see also the Nature and Gardening community. For more creative-minded projects, see also the Creative community.
This community's icon was made by Aaron Schneider, under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 license.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
@whaleross granular activated carbon for fish-tank filters is relatively less expensive - though you might be able to make your own charcoal with a fire-pit and have as effective material. Your stove hood filter probably has some kind of metal-framed and non-serviceable assembly - which could maybe be disassembled and "refilled". My vent hood filter appears to be a black piece of felt - questionable whether it actually contains carbon or not, tbh. I'd probably eventually replace it with metallic mesh in a multi-layered arrangement and not worry about carbon at all. The main role is to trap grease, not odors.
@CadeJohnson In my case it is recirculating the air so it does need to trap both grease and odors.
If you think about it though, coming into a kitchen and saying "it smells good!" is OK; if the odor is bad, maybe lack of carbon filter is not the problem! lolz I have a recirculating fan, but I don't think it does much odor trapping. Odor molecules come in all sorts of forms - some adsorb to carbon and some don't. Although activated carbon has a large capacity considering the size of the particles of carbon, it can't do miracles. Furthermore, I suspect the carbon is encased in trapped oil long before its odor-absorbing capacity is exhausted (though I guess that depends on one's cooking style).
(I posted words to this effect many hours ago, but that post seems to have been lost)