this post was submitted on 18 Jun 2023
27 points (100.0% liked)

3DPrinting

15548 readers
198 users here now

3DPrinting is a place where makers of all skill levels and walks of life can learn about and discuss 3D printing and development of 3D printed parts and devices.

The r/functionalprint community is now located at: !functionalprint@kbin.social or !functionalprint@fedia.io

There are CAD communities available at: !cad@lemmy.world or !freecad@lemmy.ml

Rules

If you need an easy way to host pictures, https://catbox.moe may be an option. Be ethical about what you post and donate if you are able or use this a lot. It is just an individual hosting content, not a company. The image embedding syntax for Lemmy is ![](URL)

Moderation policy: Light, mostly invisible

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Hi! New to the community, new to 3d printing, new to all of this.

I am heavily considering the Prusa Mini as my first printer.

  • Want a brand that is a good citizen in the 3d printing community and Prusa seems to be on this list.
  • Want a high quality printer to begin my adventure with that doesn't leave me guessing if it's my lack of skill or a lack of quality hardware.
  • Want open design to enable to tweak and improve the hardware/software as I see fit.
  • Linux user who wants full Linux support in the software stack.
  • I want to spend as little as possible on my first printer (still want high quality) because I see myself spending a lot more fairly quickly if I enjoy this as much as I suspect I will. Fortunately I can spend what I need to meet my current requirements but keeping cost down as much as possible is the goal.
  • Enjoy tinkering with hardware and software. Have a background in electronics and Linux system administration.

Would you agree that the Prusa Mini is a good starting spot considering the above?

The pricing I see in reviews etc seems to be lower then what is currently being offered on the Prusa site. Do they often have sales or specials or is this just because the cost of production has gone up? I see reviews that indicate a price of $349 but it's going for $429 on the Prusa site currently.

Should I consider adding the filament sensor and any extra build sheets? Filament from them or elsewhere?

Anything I am missing or not considering?

Any and all feedback is welcomed! Thanks ahead of time!

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] fhein@lemmy.world 0 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (1 children)

I found the Ender 3 (pro, I think) perfectly good quality. It might be due to lack of experience with anything else

How long ago did you buy it? Ender 3 was a great budget printer when it came out, but things have changed a bit since then. After Creality got the reputation of making "the best printers for beginners" it appears that they started cutting corners everywhere to increase profit margins. Genuine Meanwell power supplies were replaced with generic Chinese parts, and manufacturing quality control sometimes appear to be non-existent. Now, many customers will be lucky, and get no severe issues that can't be fixed with simple mods, but having spent quite a lot of time helping beginners on a 3d printing discord, I've seen my share of people spending days or weeks trying to calibrate their Ender, only to eventually realize that the printer itself has some issue. However if you live the US, Microcenter has been running campaigns with an E3Pro for $99. That's a good deal even though I generally don't recommend the brand.

The other thing that has changed is that the competition is much harder nowadays, and for the same cost as an Ender you can get a printer with better features. Don't get me wrong though, there are no "good" cheap Chinese printers. It's possible to get a bad unit that slipped through QC from any brand, and pretty much all models have some design flaws. My recommendation for anyone shopping on a budget is to find the "least bad" printer, or pay the premium for a genuine Prusa if they don't want to deal with upgrades and mods to fix your printer.

Next thing to be wary of when shopping Chinese printers is brand loyalty. There are no brands that is consistent when it comes to printer models. A few brands might be worth avoiding due to anti-consumer practices, but most of them have made a few decent printers, and several bad ones. Don't trust anyone claiming that one brand is good :)

Finally, many 3d printer manufacturers, including Creality, pay youtubers for "reviews", some even go as far as scripting them. Even very popular channels, who are generally very knowledgeable about 3d printing, have been caught lying about brands that compete with their sponsor, ignoring flaws on the printer they're paid to talk about, and/or rigging comparisons to come out in favour of it. There are also many fake review sites if you try to do your own research using Google. I.e. sites most likely written by a bot or someone who doesn't know anything about 3d printing themselves, so they basically only repeat stuff from the manufacturer's marketing info or copy from other sites. They can be difficult to spot for a beginner (I know I fell for them) but their goal is to make you click their Amazon affiliate links, not give you a fair review, so I think one thing they usually have in common is that all printers they list are somehow the best option for something.

I recommend people looking to buy their first printer check out this list. It's maintained by users on the 3D Printing discord. They have first hand experience with multiple printers, they've seen what kind of issues people come asking for help with, and to my knowledge haven't received any sponsorship money from any brand. Any rating is of course going to be subjective to some degree, but even if you don't trust their "top picks" the list includes common issues and known flaws for the printers, so you can prepare for what you might need to mod or upgrade if you buy it.

[–] Sticky@lemmy.world 0 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Thanks for the insightful comment! I wasn't aware of any big change in quality from Creatality, or those pretty shady review practices. I got my printer right near the start of the pandemic (May 2020), so maybe I got lucky with timing before everything went to shit :-/

If they're junk these days, that's genuinely pretty sad. Always a shame when the a product gets worse due to the manufacturer cutting quality.

[–] fhein@lemmy.world 1 points 1 year ago

Unfortunately it seems to be a recurring theme that companies start with a good, competitively priced product to gain some market share, and then reduce quality when they want to start making money. I've had it happen with food and clothes brands that I used to like too.

While the criticisms against Creality might sound bad, I wouldn't go so far to say all their printers are junk. They have a few models that aren't too bad, assuming you don't get unlucky with their lack of quality control. There are lots of countries where it's difficult to buy something other than Creality (or even worse brands, like Flashforge and XYZ Printing), and while there's a slight gamble with quality, most people can get great results from an Ender if they spend enough money and time on upgrades and troubleshooting. Though you can get better value for money, and a printer that on average requires much less upgrades and troubleshooting before it prints well.