this post was submitted on 16 Dec 2024
106 points (98.2% liked)
Lord Of The Rings Memes
193 readers
540 users here now
founded 1 week ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I never understood why the defenders were still told to hold fire at this point. Clearly the uruks are in range if an old dude who doesn't have the strength to hold the string back for long can nail one. Why not unleash the barrage while they're doing their pregame pump up ritual?
It’s a “whites of their eyes” reference. The enemy is decked out in full plate so lucky shots are all that would strike true at that range. Their hope was that the archers’ aim would improve, and therefore enemy casualties, once they scooted in a smidge. However, that underlies the overall issue of inexperience from bottom to top. Or it was just for cinematic effect, I’ve never watched the director’s commentary.
There’s also a “shock and awe” component. At that range, you’re just dealing with a bunch of random shots. Imagine instead getting up closer, and meeting a solid wall of arrows, destroying the whole front of your army!
Maybe Orcs have different psychology but that would discourage/panic most sentient beings
Considering they seem to have unlimited arrows, they should fire upon them for lucky shots, and then continue with greater accuracy as the orcs close the distance.
Yes, but
You only have so many arrows. Why waste them at extreme range? One lucky shot doesn't disprove that.
Yeah, it's not like they were waiting for last minute diplomacy.