By BoMcCready on Reddit's DataIsBeautiful
this post was submitted on 28 Aug 2024
358 points (95.4% liked)
Data is Beautiful
1179 readers
35 users here now
Be respectful
founded 5 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Where is the HIMYM hate? I never had an ending piss on the viewer more than how that train wreck ended. Made essentially 48 hours play over an entire season that meant nothing, and as an extra shocker even the twist meant nothing and only served as a reminder that the whole season meant nothing.
I wish I still had my writeup on that last season, and especially the episode How Your Mother Met Me, which I think was a genuinely terrible episode that removed all depth from the Mother, and the only reason I think it got any praise was because of the ukalele rendition of La Vie En Rose at the end.
But yes, that entire season undid 8 years of character development for most of the characters, spent the entire season building up to the Barney & Robins wedding, which it then immediately undid, spent an entire season overdeveloping Barney to being a genuinely good person whose whole persona was a simple act of benevolent revenge...only to undo it and have him revert back to being a POS womanizer (until he knocks up some lady), gives us this big buildup for Tracy only to mention in passing that she died...like seriously it was about 7 seconds, and show Ted literally and figuratively letting go of Robin once and for all...only for him be like "oh yeah if was you i loved all along at the end.
The problem is they wrote the ending to the series in season 1 so they could film it with the kids. Then the show's popularity resulted in extra seasons with more character growth that they had to erase for the ending they had already written.
Although I don't think there was ever a chance I wouldn't have been annoyed by the ending. I was annoyed through all of season 2 when Ted and Robin were dating because we were told episode 1 that she was Aunt Robin.
I liked it because that's kind of how real life actually ends up
#12
I rewatched recently, and while I love seeing the mother, that last season is quite bad.
But, GoT is worse and I refuse to watch "Season 9" of Scrubs, so HIMYM is not my priority for hate on this list.
(Also, complaints that annectdotally confirm the data don't seem to be the most useful comments.)
Try the alternate ending: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5toL5HmQl8I
This is the proper ending HIMYM should have had. It doesn't shit on the characters, and is satisfying. My head canon is this ending.