this post was submitted on 30 Jul 2024
648 points (98.4% liked)
Lord of the memes
8148 readers
247 users here now
The Lord of the rings memes communitiy on Lemmy. Share memes about Lord of the rings and be respectful.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Does anyone seriously advocate reading the Silmarillion before LOTR? If so, why?
I don’t think that would work very well. Without reading the LOTR, the Silmarillion is a rebel without a cause. It’s a pointless creation myth. The reader has no investment in the characters or their development as there’s no real story or arc to them.
Read the LOTR and The Hobbit, and if the reader loves Middle Earth, they can dig deeper into the world building of it all.
Children of Hurin is an interesting read. Reading the Silmarillion felt a bit like a chore to me but Children of Hurin is well put together as a story that hold up on his own.
PS: For those that don't know Children of Hurin is part of the Silmarillion. J.R.R Tolkien's son (Christopher Tolkien) took this story, filled up the blank using his dad notes to turn this story into a full novel.
I liked Children of Hurin, but it’s more of a dark tale like old, old stories and legends where nobody ends up having a good life. It’s almost all tragedy.
It is definitely a tragedy, not a light read for sure
Hobbit first though, right?
That's not how a modernist consumes.
It goes "core fandom", prequel, pre-prequel (creation myth), then inevitably sequels if they didn't arrive before or in between the prequels.
We're going to get some random actor one day playing Aragorn's son and it'll be indistinguishable from a PG-13 version of Game of Thrones by a writing team where two of them skimmed the books and most of them have seen one or more of the movies at some point, and they kind of love the setting but don't love the lack of grey morals. There will be a tribe of orcs that are totally good guys now. (they will be basically the exact same as the sharks from finding Nemo, because that will be the writing team's inspiration and they will be very hyped about it)
Man, somebody gazed into Hollywood's palantir. This is scary believable lol 😮
Whichever you prefer, but chronologically…yes. That would be the better choice.
I mean, creation myths are pointless anyways.
They are stories that can easily help writers write more stories, and many find them entertaining.
We’re talking fantasy storyland here. How many times have you finished a good set of books and just wished maybe there were more even though the author ended the series? If you’re a fan of Tolkien’s world building then the Silmarillion is a lovely addition to the mythos of the land and adds to the magic of it all.
I’ve read it twice and quite enjoyed the introductions of the characters we meet in the rest of the books. It really adds a lot of sense to how old some of the characters are, and most of all (imo) it lends strongly to the sadness of the passing of magic from the land that is intimated by Tolkien.
found the atheist
I can't even tell wtf you are
https://i.imgur.com/J1G4iNc.png
deist.
musician
programmer
father
nomad
pick one
Oh wow, I'd loathe to be a son of yours.
guess again
I don't think that is a common recommendation.
I definitely recommend not doing that, does that count?