At this point, it's not the communities, it's the engagement.
this post was submitted on 22 Dec 2023
19 points (100.0% liked)
Moving to: m/AskMbin!
19 readers
1 users here now
### We are moving! **Join us in our new journey as we take a new direction towards the future for this community at mbin, find our new community here and read this post to know more about why we are moving. Thank you and we hope to see you there!**
founded 1 year ago
Bingo.
All the niche communities exist it's just that nobody comments or posts anything for months on end. I actually think that the existence of many of the same communities on different instances is the main hurdle here. Drawback of the concept of the fediverse I suppose but it does make the experience on Lemmy much poorer in that regard.
If there is no engagement there is no community. It is just a place.
just that nobody comments or posts anything for months on end
I post regularly in some magazines, yet nobody reply or interact
Same here. It's content about a thing that I want to see. Even if I get little to no engagement, hopefully whoever stumbles upon it will be somewhat entertained.
This is a double edged sword. If we had enough people that the smaller communities filled out the main communities would be overridden with people instead of the small community feel we have now everywhere you go.
I'll take 1 10,000 user community over 10,000 1 user communities.
Redundancy is sometimes redundant.
What's the draw of having such a small community though? And why do you think that main communities would be overriden? Honest questions here I don't quite understand what you are concerned about. I personally think that it's the main problem with the fediverse right now, it's only flavorless general posts and nothing from small niche interest that drew me to reddit in the first place.
True, but I was still curious about what communities get mentioned here. And also, without communities catering to different users' interests, there will be no engagement.
Art/design related communities. I made a few here but I was the only one posting. Also miss the model making/diorama/mini painting subs. And some other little niche hobby communities.
Oh also local city communities are basically nonexistent here and it will prob take years for that to become viable here.
I miss the regional/local subs. While there's technically a few for my region spread across different instances, none of them have much, if any, activity.
Of the more "niche" communities, the one I miss the most is r/fosteranimals. I started one here, and have posted a few times, but given the already limited audience, plus my inexperience at growing/moderating a community, and my tendency to be mostly a lurker, I have not managed any engagement in the community beyond up/down votes.
There are some small, niche reddit communities I miss. Unfortunately since this part of the fediverse is small, the niche communities are even smaller. Either moderated by one person and no posts, or it just doesn't exist.
A populated am I the asshole. That one really needs a critical mass of all sorts of people to be fun. When my GF and I go out to eat we generally pull the top posts of the week and talk em over while we eat. It's a great conversation starter and a wonderful way to find out little stories that don't come up in everyday conversation.
Essentially all of the ones that I used. r/Minecraft, r/minecraftsuggestions, r/conlangs, r/vexillology, r/pixelart, etc.
The thing is that all of these have communities and magazines on the fediverse — it's just that there's little, if any, activity on them. I don't think you can really say that these communities are here if they have one person posting on them regularly.
The only communities that actually have a solid amount of activity here are ones about memes and news. If that's all that you used Reddit for, then the fediverse is doing great, and such people will act baffled at how anyone could stay on or miss Reddit. But for everyone else, the content just isn't there.
Same thing for ttrpgs. That was pretty much all I used reddit for the last few years. It has since just gone away. I've functionally stopped accruing new rpg creators and news.
Also comics. I followed a lot of new creators in the last few years. Most of them only post on Reddit.
was polandball and geometry dash subs
Yeah, it'd be nice to see an active Geometry Dash community given that 2.2 just released. /m/geometrydash is in the abandoned magazines section, so I might request ownership and try to get a bit of activity going there.
ü
/r/BestOfRedditorUpdates
I still go back to read the weekly /top posts. Lots of interesting drama.
malicious compliance
while curbing the number of “challenged the cook to test my spice tolerance and lost” posts
Some very nische anime communitys, but that would require more users in the first place.
r/hotas
r/trackball
It's deffo r/Flairwars and r/Num for me, despite not having been in the latter in the time I was on that site.
Both have their own unique inside jokes, battling systems, lore, fanworks, and most of all, a slow yet steadily thriving community that's accepting of everyone. I often wonder how my first aforementioned community would thrive in this vast federated space, especially with all the new possibilities out here... Maybe new lore expansions, and a reinvigoration on the way?
There are some small niche communities that I miss interacting with because the people were pretty cool. Mostly warhammer and some smaller game communities.
Grimdank made it over here if that's one of the ones you're missing, would love more Warhammer memes
Edit: @grimdank
Eyeblech.
It's one of the reasons I created Morbid Curiosity in Kbin, to push things a little towards such material!
An actual active Writing Prompts.
Lately I've been having to go back to Reddit to look at the gloryhammer and Dyson sphere program subs. The 2nd one has been more used after the recent update, just wish I could load any mods
The fandom in the Godzilla sub was super active on Reddit. Not much going on here really. Some chatter recently from the buzz Minus One has been getting, but I miss the daily active discussions and dumb memes from people actually plugged in to the community.
The hololive and vtuber communities weren't able to make the switch. They're here but they're not active enough to actually keep up with.
Plus the talents related don't know fediverse exists and barely even knew reddit existed, so they generally only post on reddit if anywhere (they mostly are only aware of twitter)
I just started shroom hunting when I left Reddit. I’ve learned a fair bit about growing mushrooms since then on the fediverse but I know little about identifying them. I keep finding wild portobellos and I’m too scared to try them! (Yes, identified by gill, cap, spore, and stem discoloration)
I still check /r/hockey for sports news since I feel like it's the best way to keep up on all events compared to Shitter or HFBoards. The quality of discussion and friendliness of the community had been pretty good from between 2010-2020, a really good stretch that I can't say was the same for most subreddits I used to follow. From 2020 on, there was a rapid change in tone on that subreddit as more and more angry dbags from Shitter started to frequent it more regularly and it became a not so fun place to engage with anymore.
I recently inherited /m/hockey here. I plan on being more active there in the near future by trying to create multi-topic news summary posts on a weekly basis.
I miss the VRChat sub myself. Not much of it here. There's more on the microblog side of the magazine but very few threads. Maybe I'll start posting patch notes that they put into discord there. A Resonite community would be nice too but I don't think that platform has enough users currently to make a thriving sub here yet.
You know what I think I'm just going to request ownership over it and see if I can do anything with it.
/r/nosleep
I can’t get enough of the, often shoddy, short form horror.
/r/ancientcoins
Interesting mix of people, most of whom were chill. Always something new to discover. And they were pretty open to discussing the elephant in the room: much of everyone's collection had been looted at some point. The only notable exception to that was an AMA by a Jr. Sales Person from Harlan Berk. He got roasted.
The rest of this is just me ranting about coins.
Coins are a relatively new invention. The first recognizable coins were made in Lydia (modern day Turkey) around 600BCE. For perspective, Egypt's Old and New Kingdoms did not have standardized, metallic currency. (which is a shame - considering Egypt's art, their currency probably would have looked awesome).
Greek coinage emphasized art and sometimes local trade items. For example, if your city was famous for its horses your coins would probably feature horses.
Celtic coins often looked like their artists were eating every mushroom they could get their hands on.
Roman coins emphasized political power, and had a lasting impact on the rest of coinage in the west. For example, they standardized putting the Leader's head on the obverse, and an uplifting design on the reverse. Sometimes they'd put the Emperor's wife on the front, which is always fun. (Curiously, Canadians that I've talked to about this are obstinate that the Queen is on the back and that the Bluenose/Loon/Beaver/whatever is on the front.)
Of course China had its own monetary progression. Ant Nose Money and Spade Money, for example, preceded the round coin with square hole that has been prevalent for the past 1200-ish years. India produced some really cool square coins. Japan minted one and two "Bu" coins that were rectangular during the 1800s - and although that's stretching the definition of ancient, I think they're cool.
So yeah, I miss being subscribed to COIN FACTS.
DigitalMinimalism
It was quiet, but people would sometimes discuss various way for preventing screens etc from being too much a part of their daily lives.
I kinda miss the activity of r/BobsBurgers, since it's one of my favorite shows, but at the same time, it can be a bit circlejerk-y with users hating on the change in direction the show went in, especially after the movie not too long ago. I don't miss that lol.
japanfinance, japanlife, etc. It's not about the communities themselves, it's about the huge amount of knowledge and experience that rests in the people engaging with them
r/hypixel
r/hypixelskyblock
Conlangs, mostly