Thanks Biden
this post was submitted on 20 Dec 2024
91 points (100.0% liked)
Politics
10192 readers
86 users here now
In-depth political discussion from around the world; if it's a political happening, you can post it here.
Guidelines for submissions:
- Where possible, post the original source of information.
- If there is a paywall, you can use alternative sources or provide an archive.today, 12ft.io, etc. link in the body.
- Do not editorialize titles. Preserve the original title when possible; edits for clarity are fine.
- Do not post ragebait or shock stories. These will be removed.
- Do not post tabloid or blogspam stories. These will be removed.
- Social media should be a source of last resort.
These guidelines will be enforced on a know-it-when-I-see-it basis.
Subcommunities on Beehaw:
This community's icon was made by Aaron Schneider, under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 license.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Shame he didn't do it a few months ago.
Now do the rest, coward. We're literally about to descend into fascism, who cares what a corrupt Supreme Court says?
he already did that. you see when the court says no it does not happen. repeating it won't make it happen any more.
And they will stop him how exactly?
same way they did before. by denying it. its the same reason the south korean president was not able to keep his martial law thing going.
The Supreme Court denial is just words. He stopped implementing the previous plan because he accepted and followed those words, but he could not. Maybe his bureaucracy will reject him and refuse to go against the Supreme Court words, but that's a question for his bureaucracy.
And yes, that's how coups work. Sometimes the army/police/whatever backs down because some other entity in the civil power structure says "you can't do that". And other times, they don't. It's all decided based on the perceived power and righteousness of the two sides, not because the court just decides stuff and then it happens by some sort of magic.
Exactly my point, and I'm glad you were here to argue it better than I could. Like yeah, in normal times I don't want Biden to flaunt what the Supreme Court says, even if they are conservative. But the GOP has stopped playing by the rules, and Trump is going to break so many rules and laws over his presidency that we will wonder what "legal" even means anymore. So who cares if Biden flaunts the Supreme Court in his final month?
Can't trump just reneg on this? I am not American, but I thought Biden canceled a bunch already and had to walk it back
He can forgive federal loans of people with government jobs easier. To do it for people that don't have public sector jobs he needs congressional approval, and they fought back hard on that when he tried it. I don't believe they'd be able to unforgive the debts, but IANAL.
Depends on the definition of "being able to":
(IANAL, but those two are)
He announced a broad cancellation that was going to happen months in the future, and the courts paused and then later said it wasn't allowed. If it had progressed very quickly it would have been harder to block. One could argue it was intended to give the court a chance to block it.
This current forgiveness is an executive order, so if it's not completed by the time Trump is the executive he can stop it easily.
Also even his repayment plan was sued and blocked :/
Blocking the SAVE plan is an absolute scam. "Sorry, not scamming students is unconstitional"
I can only speak from across the pond, but that's likely the strategy. It has no downsides for the current administration - but the incoming administration either has to cancel it and look like the shitheads (not that they seem to care about that), or run with it to save face, and try and find the budget for it.
This is great! But is it means tested?
I just don't want any rich kids getting free school. Those damn rich kids and their student loan schemes.
Means testing has been a thorn in the side of american social safety nets for a long time. It creates a very easy way to lower benefits (the means line) and tends to result in reducing effectiveness as folks who could use a bit of help and then could move to the positive colomn tend not to recieve it but others who technically should not can by being immoral and paperwork savy. It also creates a larger beuracracy of those who have to evaluate the means criteria. just no please.
There is still ton bureaucracy to get this forgiveness
im talking about the actual civil service will not break the law because the president tells them to. thats what I meant by the bureaucracy. as much as it gets shit on bereaucracy is actually good for a well functioning society. we just want it organized and efficient as possible.
No... And this has nothing to do with Biden either beyond him allowing doe do its job as required by law.
Anyone who works at a qualified public interest job is a eligible for forgiveness after 120 payments.
There are a lot of lawyers with massive student loans who work for fed gov making over 100k who benefit from this. 10 years wipe loans clean them go into private to make the real money.
We are literally funding training of the owner class' foot soldiers
But right brain rot is hurt becuase nurses or social workers get the benefit. Tells you what you need to know where they got their info from.
This is spot on. And honestly, public service workers make so little compared to industry, it really doesn’t matter if they’re from a wealthy family or not - if they (public workers) have student loans, the forgiveness is deserved.
10 years can be difficult to get. I’ve known people who work for non-profits for 5 years or more, only to be let go because grant money was drying up.
So because a couple of rich kids get free school, literally thousands of others can go get fucked. Thank God we stopped those 3 rich kids from getting free education.
That'll show those rich assholes who's boss.
Who cares about all the collateral damage when you can stick it to some rich kid who... Checks notes... Can just pay for it anyway like it never mattered in the first place. Meanwhile, poor people have to end up with 3 jobs just to make the interest payment.
You're a clown and a fool.
I think the comment you were answering is sarcastic.
Perhaps, but means testing is a Republican dog whistle that people will belt out with their full chest.
Rich kids don't have student loans
That's the joke, I think