Why not a second user profile?
this post was submitted on 05 Aug 2024
37 points (91.1% liked)
Privacy
32120 readers
361 users here now
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn't great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don't promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Not sure why i didnt think of using the stock option for this tbh. But isnt that what shelter and these apps do anyway? What are the differences?
I'm just an average user, I don't think I can give an accurate answer... But check this out...
Super helpful community. Tons of info available.
With Graphene, the recommended way is to use separate profiles, not Shelter or similar apps. Check out the official Graphene account on their forum:
https://discuss.grapheneos.org/d/12503-shelter-versus-native-gos-app-isolation-tradeoffs/10
thanks for pointing this out :)
I have a Pixel 8 pro (with stock OS) and use Shelter to isolate my work apps. I have not had any issues. Super nice being able to just pause the whole suite of apps when I'm on PTO / away and don't want to be bothered.
You realize even if its isolated that if anything ever goes wrong at work, they have every right to take your phone yeah?
Never put work things on a personal phone. I don't know if im just lucky, or if you have every right to do this but; if work requires putting something on your phone, make them buy you a new phone, a work specific phone. I've had to sign a few contracts ensuring the phone lives, but I've atleast never had to hand over a personal phone for work.
(With the added benefit of being able to turn off my work phone and being fully free from work)
You realize even if its isolated that if anything ever goes Wrong at work, they have every right to take your phone yeah?
I'm sure you have a law to point, right? Because it sure sounds made up.
There is no law, because its not illegal to do. Or maybe I'm wrong and their is a law specifically saying its okay to do this.
Bottom line? Any time work has told me to get a work related app, or whenever it was hinted at, you can bet your ass that they'll have some you sign something as well.
I've also heard plenty of stories that this has happened. Don't learn the hard way by installing work related apps on your personal phone.
Not to mention the few times I've told work that I simply will not install a work related app, and have gotten work phones.
There is no law, because its not illegal to do. Or maybe I'm wrong and their is a law specifically saying its okay to do this.
They have the right to take your property but that law isn't written anywhere? I agree you're wrong, but not on what you think
Yes, that is how contracts work, similar to how Terms and Conditions generally allow websites to take any data they'd like from you, and sign away rights like class action law suits. Contracts can also say that if you have work property on your phone, they have every right to take your phone.
You clearly have never worked somewhere where said company requires you to have a work app, and it shows.
Oooh, so now it's a contract thing... Still BS and made up, but I like how you backtrack.
And yes, I've worked in companies that require a work app. Some gave a phone, others allow to install in your. Current is a fortune 50 that allows installing on your own using Intune.
And you can be sure they are smart enough to not try to take away employee property because contracts with illegal terms are not enforceable, so they don't even try.
I guess you're used to being treated badly, in which case I'm sorry for you.
I guess in your case you're just financially secure enough to never have to worry.
I didn't back track at all, its always been a contract. I've seen this happen, and its the reason why I would never tell someone to ever allow company material on a personal phone, this isn't even some obscure advice, it should be well known.
Stop trying to sound like you know everything when you've specifically said you've never experienced this. It has happened, it can happen, it will happen. Put yourself in a safe position by never allowing company apps, material, email, anything on a personal phone.
I've used Island in the past and it worked fine
Island doesnt block main profile contact snooping by an app in the work profile. I recommend shelter for anyone who isnt set on either.
Interesting, could you share the fdroid link to that? Not seeing it on fdroid/droidify
Looks like it's only on the play store and GitHub, you could use obtainium. But it's not been updated since 2023 apparently.
You dont need shelter. Just create another user profile.
Would love to but switching profiles crashes my 6a and restarts the phone every time. Wish this problem would be fixed as it makes switching profiles so annoying and using a a service like shelter more convenient.
I would probably focus on getting that fixed and tell your employer that they need to provide you a work phone or pay you a stipen.
Profiles are a pretty big feature to not having working on Android in general but, especially on Graphene.
I use it daily, it works wihtout issues for me, I don't know what these dudes are talking about.
whenever i install an app from normal profile to work profile the installer just get stuck and i need to relaunch the app..
May not be best for privacy but very convenient. I have few apps which require google play services. I had them installed in work profile along with play services. When I am not using them, I simply turn off work profile. My main profile does not have play services installed.
Short answer: No