I mean, if you're willing to view TLJ as a standalone film, why wouldn't you also grant the same reprieve to TFA? They were both cinematically beautiful and told internally consistent and compelling stories, but they looked like dogshit against the backdrop of the rest of the Skywalker storyline and the fundamentals of the SW universe. I just give TFA more leeway because it didn't intentionally retcon its own set-up material.

[–] TallonMetroid@lemmy.world 2 points 5 months ago

Yeah, TFA is bland corporate cookie cutter crap, but it's at least not deliberately hostile to people who actually liked Star Wars going in. But on the other hand, the fact that it was greenlit as a mainline Star Wars movie was rather indicative that either Disney didn't actually care to properly vet what they were putting out, or that I was very definitely not part of the target audience they wanted. So I haven't watched or read anything else since.