this post was submitted on 02 Apr 2024
9 points (100.0% liked)

Communism

30 readers
1 users here now

For the abolition of the current state of things

Questions are appreciated. Debate and discussion, when emphatic, is welcome.

Please do not do atrocity denial, authoritarian apologia, whataboutism, or anti-communism. The general toxicity of Lemmygrad and Hexbar are not welcome here.

founded 8 months ago
MODERATORS
 

One way of being anti-anti-utopian is to be utopian. It’s crucial to keep imagining that things could get better, and furthermore to imagine how they might get better. Here no doubt one has to avoid Berlant’s “cruel optimism,” which is perhaps thinking and saying that things will get better without doing the work of imagining how. In avoiding that, it may be best to recall the Romain Rolland quote so often attributed to Gramsci, “pessimism of the intellect, optimism of the will.” Or maybe we should just give up entirely on optimism or pessimism—we have to do this work no matter how we feel about it. So by force of will or the sheer default of emergency we make ourselves have utopian thoughts and ideas. This is the necessary next step following the dystopian moment, without which dystopia is stuck at a level of political quietism that can make it just another tool of control and of things-as-they-are. The situation is bad, yes, okay, enough of that; we know that already. Dystopia has done its job, it’s old news now, perhaps it’s self-indulgence to stay stuck in that place any more. Next thought: utopia. Realistic or not, and perhaps especially if not.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] MercurySunrise 1 points 6 months ago

In my experience as an American, too many people do not know. They live in these extremely weird tightly controlled bubbles of reality. Utopianism is incredibly important, but so is recognizing dystopia. It's like communism without the anarchism, or anarchism without the communism. It's an ideological hole. We need both perspectives to build a healthier society. I think people will not feel moved to change and push for utopia if they do not understand why they must change.