Classroom of the Elite: first two seasons were fun, looking forward to season 3
Bottom-tier Character Tomozaki: first season was OK, I'm interested in where the story will go
Mato Seihei no Slave: I vaguely recall someone saying there was something good about the source material
MASHLE: first season was OK, I'm not very interested in S2, I might binge it when the season is complete
Blue Exorcist: oh, another season. It's been a while. I remember liking the first season and being confused at the start of the second season (it's about 6 years between each season, so maybe I just forgot some important details. From a S2 MAL review: "the season does not follow the end of season 1. Episodes 18-25 were not canon and accordingly, they do not exist in season 2", I didn't know this, so maybe that was my problem)
The Dangers in My Heart: first season was fantastic, excited for the second season
A Sign of Affection: the source material is rated highly on MAL, I'll give it a shot
Banished from the Hero's Party: First season was OK
TSUKIMICHI: I liked the first season, looking forward to the second season
The Foolish Angel Dances with the Devil: I saw the PV, I'll give it a shot
Cherry Magic!: The source material is rated well on MAL, I'll give it a shot
The Witch and the Beast: The source material is rated well on MAL, I'll give a shot
The Weakest Tamer Began a Journey to Pick Up Trash: WILDCARD, I dunno, it sounds like absolute trash from the title, but I think I'll give it a shot anyways