this post was submitted on 11 Oct 2023
10 points (100.0% liked)
literature.cafe chat
393 readers
1 users here now
Local off topic chat for literature.cafe, any and all are welcome. For discussions of books and beyond! Please follow instance rules. Although focused for literature.cafe users, any and all are welcome!
To find more communities on this instance, go to: !411@literature.cafe
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Finished The Fifth Season, enjoyed it so much that I have jumped straight into book 2 - The Obelisk Gate. So far I like it slightly less, but it's still very good. It's interesting to see an actual book written at least partially in 2nd person - I'm an avid fanfiction reader and the application of 2nd person in fanfics is... usually really clumsy, so it's refreshing to see that it can be used to great effect.
Personally, I found the Obelisk Gate to be the least engaging of the trilogy (and it’s still good!), but it helps to set up the third book, and the pay off is worth it.
I read that trilogy but don't remember The Obelisk Gate being in 2nd person, which must be a testament to Jemison's skills as a writer. I was so sad when I tried to read Harrow the Ninth and so much of it was in 2nd person. I gave up.
The whole trilogy is like 50% in second person, actually :P (well, I don't know about book 3 yet but if the current trend holds...)
Huh, thanks for the warning about Harrow, haven't had the chance to dive in yet - I'll give it a shot anyway but I like to be prepared for surprise 2nd person.
I might give it another try, since today I read some reviews that say the 2nd person perspective is important to the story somehow so now I'm really curious!
It is important to the story, but you are not the first one I heard that had troubles with it. I didn’t struggle with it at all, but it does add a lot
Good to know. I really enjoyed Gideon the Ninth and wanted to pop back into that world again.