this post was submitted on 10 Oct 2022
15 points (100.0% liked)
History
1858 readers
1 users here now
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
He himself did not rape anyone. Murder also has a specific definition. Under his rule people were put to death (both the spanish and the natives) for breaking laws the rulers enacted. So you could make the argument it wasn't murder. We don't call people who die under the death penalty murder. (some might but it's generally understood to be something different) It's also not fair to them that you think you could have done better having not lived in such a time. You don't know that you could have. You don't have as much responsibility as he does. Multiple times he chastised his men for being violent. We can see from the historical record he had the capacity for both good and evil.
I feel like I want to bring up a few more historical figures here to bring perspective.
George Washington the founding leader of the united states had slaves. Multiple roads, states and more are named after him. He did some great and amazing things. He also had slaves, literal slaves. He could have freed them at anytime.
Lets not forget he had slaves, but also not forget all the good things he did and even he started to recognize slavery was evil.
Agreed but the reverse has been true. As the video I posted pointed out, many people are outright lying and misrepresenting what he said and did. We need push back on the otherside to make sure we are getting the whole accurate picture.
The holiday is still Columbus day in most places. Some places instead celebrate indigenous but it has not been officially country wide renamed.
Accept nothing, ask for proof of everything. You can never assume there is no agenda or bias against the article, person, or entity.
Every line of history is up for debate always and forever. We thought he was the first European until Leaf Erickson's camp was discovered.
We should be discussing the actual In language writings, who wrote them, what their various translations mean instead of opinion articles and youtube videos. Even if they are both good places to start.
Cheers
how much more colonialism is gonna be on here before lemmy rightfully purges it?