this post was submitted on 05 Aug 2023
60 points (98.4% liked)

Hobbit Art

585 readers
1 users here now

Any sort of Middle Earth legendarium artwork is ok. It doesn't need to be made by or about hobbits.

Please give attribution to the original artist when possible.

It is not required, but if you know, please talk a bit about the scene in the image. What's going on? Who is in it? Why is it happening? Do you like it? Why?

Don't forget about the other hobbit forums here: !hobbits@hobbit.world !hobbit_games@hobbit.world

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

I know Bakshi's version has A LOT of issues, but I grew up watching it again and again and I have very fond memories of it. I'm aware I am in the minority.

One of the scenes I love is Boromir's death (video link)... if you can ignore the "not-enough-budget" Uruk-hai. I like the roughness and lack of music once Boromir's is hit with the first arrow.

Source of the image: The Lord of the Rings (1978) โ€“ Mutant Reviewers

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[โ€“] Crul@lemmy.world 2 points 1 year ago

It's a matter of taste, so no one is wrong here.

For example Legolas in this (while butt-fucking ugly) shows concern and genuine shock whereas elves in the Jackson films are generally stoic.

That's a hard one. I don't have a strong opinion about each take. Legolas is not one of the best characters on Bakshi's film, and I don't remember enough about the book to say which one is more faithfull (if that's something you appreciate).

I just find the dichotomy interesting, I do revere Jackson's work as masterpieces of cinema.

Just to be clear: I think Jackson's films are incomparably better product than Bakshi's, they are not on the same league. 1978 version is not even finished! The only way you could compare them is by factoring their bugdets. But I don't know how to "divide my opinions by a number", hehe.

I like having both so people can choose, or watch both.