this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2023
1569 points (79.2% liked)

Memes

45727 readers
550 users here now

Rules:

  1. Be civil and nice.
  2. Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] Zagorath@aussie.zone 3 points 1 year ago

China being a dictatorship of the proletariat

Is it, though? I certainly don't see the Chinese political leadership needing to put in considerable labour for their income. In practice, they don't look so different from American business and political elites, to me.

US being a dictatorship of the bourgeoisie

Look I understand where you're coming from with this, and when you're talking about America in particular I'm relatively on board. But I suspect this was intended to refer to western capitalist democracies more broadly, and while I understand what you mean, I simply don't agree that it's fair to call a democracy using a serious democratic system running free and fair elections a "dictatorship" in the same paragraph as you're calling China a dictatorship, as though the two are comparable.

Yeah, FPTP is fundamentally anti-democratic, and most democracies have some flaws in how free or fair they are, with the result being that they're less than perfectly democratic. The US is particularly bad, but even worse is a place like Singapore, which barely pretends to be a fair democracy. But if you mean to suggest the same of countries like Australia, France, and Germany, I'm just not on board. To pretend even America is on the same level of being a dictatorship as China is ludicrous.

I say this as someone who is rather anti-capitalist in general. In theory, I think the ideals of socialism are fantastic, and from what I've seen socialists say about how the system could work, I don't disagree.

But then I see socialists do things like pretend America is just as much of a dictatorship as China or (as I saw the creator of the explicitly socialist Second Thought YouTube channel "Second Thought" do on his news channel) side with Russia (or at least, against NATO and Ukraine) in Russia's invasion of Ukraine, or blame America for China's aggressive policy towards Taiwan. And as much as I'm on board with socialist economic ideals, I also fundamentally believe in the rights of individual freedoms afforded by liberal democracies.

I don't think that these have to be in conflict, but for some reason every time I see someone espousing socialism they seem to end up supportive highly oppressive regimes like China and Russia. It makes it very hard (read: impossible) to actually take that final step into embracing the label of "socialist".