this post was submitted on 08 Apr 2024
845 points (95.9% liked)
People Twitter
4972 readers
925 users here now
People tweeting stuff. We allow tweets from anyone.
RULES:
- Mark NSFW content.
- No doxxing people.
- Must be a tweet or similar
- No bullying.
- Be excellent to each other.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
God doesn't make mistakes.
So if God made somebody trans, then they're trans.
Moreover, by their own stories not only did God intentionally make that person trans but God likely deliberately did so to test the people interacting with said trans person on if they could love the trans person as required by their faith.
But no. It's never that because the religious argument is just a post hoc justification for the hate.
The other day I suggested fighting climate change was a net benefit even if it were "hoax." This some offended their Christian sensibilities and I was told:
That god thingy made mistakes since time immemorial. Read the bible.
They're not real mistakes. The end justifies the means and they think their god is only smart enough to go with this, basically.
The ends justify the means?
Hypotheticaly then: if I had a 100% guarantee that murdering all babies would get them into heaven, but you'd go to hell, is it morally right to murder all babies? The ends justify the means, do they not? We need to get babies to heaven! So murder them all!
No, it's absolutely still monstrous. Because utilitarianism is stupid.
Stanislaw Lem had a short story about something like this. Basically a missionary came to a planet populated by cute innocent fur balls. He taught them the Bible, so they tortured him to death to make him a martyr and guarantee that he gets to haven, knowingly condemning themselves to hell out of compassion for the priest.
The flipside is: why tf is Judas considered a bad guy? Without him, no one could have ever gone to heaven
Oh, no. That's not okay. But, if we did do that, then it's for the best.
If you do it it's not ok and you should feel guilty all of your life. But if we did it it's totally ok.
Actually you should still feel guilty all of your life because one of your ancestors sinned or something. And I've made you a sinner by definition.
-- God, priests and other representatives of God, probably.
Also, can we have more gold?
No, that's just god testing them, because that definitely makes sense.
Sure God. Sure.
I like your way of thinking but for a Christian it doesn't work like that. They will likely say that despite God's intentions, this person went consciously against God's will and decided to commit a sin (because God gave us free will).
And then good luck explaining to them how nobody in their right mind would want to be ridiculed, cast out, ostracised, hated by so many people and become trans just simply out of spite.